#104225: "The order of target in an AOE attack MATTERS (This made me lost the game, while I SHOULN'T HAVE)"
What is this report about?
What happened ? Please select from below
What happened ? Please select from below
Please check if there is already a report on the same subject
If yes, please VOTE for this report. Reports with the most votes are taken care of in PRIORITY!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Detailed description
-
• Please copy/paste the error message you see on your screen, if any.
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. -
• Please explains what you wanted to do, what you do and what happened
Step 135-136.
• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Please copy/paste the text displayed in English instead of your language. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here. Is this text available in the translation system? If yes, has it been translated for more than 24 hours?
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Please explain your suggestion precisely and concisely so that it's as easy as possible to understand what you mean.
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• What was displayed on the screen when you were blocked (Blank screen? Part of the game interface? Error message?)
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Which part of the rules was not respected by the BGA adaptation
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. -
• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
Step 135-136.
• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Which was the game action you wanted to do?
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. -
• What do you try to do to trigger this game action?
Step 135-136.
-
• What happened when you try to do this (error message, game status bar message, ...)?
• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• At which step of the game did the problem occurs (what was the current game instruction)?
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. -
• What happened when you try to do a game action (error message, game status bar message, ...)?
Step 135-136.
• What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Please describe the display issue. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Please copy/paste the text displayed in English instead of your language. If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here. Is this text available in the translation system? If yes, has it been translated for more than 24 hours?
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
-
• Please explain your suggestion precisely and concisely so that it's as easy as possible to understand what you mean.
My Korvash attacked THREE enemies with "Chop", two of whom (Tsu Xiao, Dugrun) would be taken out of action after this attack, and one of whom (Nevamor) wouldn't.
My opponent had "Revenge" in his hand, and played "Revenge" to Nevamor. Since Nevamor isn't taken out of action, "Revenge" dealt damage to Korvash and took Korvash out of action.
What I can't understand is, WHY, are Tsu Xiao and Dugrun, still darn alive ?????? (and this made me lose 18 ELO points)
My oppenent said this is because the attack targeted Nevamore first, so "Revenge" resolved before the damage to the two other champions. Then, why in the world is Nevamore the first target, as "Chop" is an AOE attack?
In an AOE attack, I believe that the player who attacks should decide the order of the targets. But BGA just decided it for us, and we have completely no idea why the order is so !
In my case, if Tsu Xiao or Dugrun is the first target, then I wouldn't have lost (in contrast, I would have been close to victory). But , SURPRISE! Nevamor is the first target! So I lose, oh yeah!
This is really frustrating, since my high rank made my hard to earn ELOs. And this darn bug made me lose 18 ELO at once. THANKS.
Please do not ignore the subtle parts of the rules. They can matter a lot. • What is your browser?
Google Chrome v119
Report history
I have consulted this problem in the Super Fantasy Brawl community. It seems that in fact, an AOE attack is simultaneously resolved. Any reaction played in an AOE attack should be resolved after the damage.
...Then this is really a bug that need fixing...
Add something to this report
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appears several time? Everytime? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use a picture hosting service of your choice (snipboard.io for example) to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
